Legendary singer Bob Dylan, who was awarded the Nobel prize for literature for his powerful lyrics, sang “Forever Young” in 1974. Still popular after more than half a century, it was meant as a benediction, a blessing. Yet, for many adult Indians, “forever young” is often a curse: typical Indian parents continue to treat their offspring as children long after they have become adults.Parental rules, directions, and admonitions — meant for pre- and early-teen youngsters — are applied to adults, seeking ongoing control over their lives.
As if this is not bad enough, we have governments which treat citizens like children, mimicking domineering parents. Increasingly playing this role, our governments — in states and at the Centre — seek to dictate what we eat, drink, wear, watch on the cine, television or phone screen, who we befriend, where we celebrate, and much more. Like parents, governments too imagine this is in our best interest.
The nanny role of government may or may not be uniquely Indian. Many would attribute it to our colonial history and the rulers’ imperative to lay down laws for the control of their subjects. Yet, it derives from a longer past; then, too, it was the same ruler (king) and “pracha” (supplicant) relationship. Today, what drives it is the continuance of a feudal/hierarchical mindset. “Equality of status” is enshrined in our Constitution, with the aim of changing this deep-rooted societal structure. However, it is all but non-existent in so many day-to-day experiences; worse, regulations and practices are contrary to the goal of equality.
Welcome to Civil Society's
new website!
Login to Civil Society by entering your email below